A car charging at a public charger in the UK.

The best non-tesla electric cars (according to Reddit)

Explore top non-Tesla EVs!
X min
  • Reddit is emerging as a valuable resource for EV enthusiasts, sharing experiences and advice.
  • There a few strong competitors against Tesla's EVs, each offering unique benefits in design, performance, or affordability.
  • Non-Tesla electric cars may lack the same level of exhilaration and excitement that Tesla vehicles are known for, though they can still provide an enjoyable driving experience.
Get one month free when you subscribe for six consecutive months with Drive Fuze. Use code HOP2024!

In today's market, a diverse range of non-Tesla electric cars is gaining immense popularity, partly driven by flexible monthly subscriptions which have gained massive popularity this year.

When scouring the internet for the best non-Tesla electric car, one platform emerges as a go-to destination for advice and insights – Reddit. The Reddit community has established itself as a valuable resource for electric vehicle enthusiasts, where passionate individuals gladly share their experiences, reviews, and expert knowledge to help others make informed decisions.

Since Tesla doesn't make non-electric cars, we decided to collected the best EV alternatives to Tesla cars in one place. Read on!

Alternatives to Model 3

When it comes to electric cars, Tesla's Model 3 is undoubtedly one of the most popular choices. It's been in the top 10 best-selling vehicles in the UK for a few years. However, several other non-Tesla electric cars deserve your consideration. Here are some noteworthy alternatives:

1. Polestar 2

The Polestar 2 is a premium electric sedan prioritising sustainability and minimalistic design. 

Its exceptional range and driving dynamics make it an excellent option for those looking for a non-Tesla electric car with a touch of Scandinavian style. It's an EV often recommended as a direct Model 3 competitor by Reddit users.

2. BMW i4

The BMW i4 is a luxury electric car combining elegance and powerful performance. Its sleek exterior and cutting-edge technology make it a compelling choice for those seeking a high-end electric driving experience.

3. Volkswagen ID.3

The VW ID.3 is a compact electric car with an impressive range for its size and stylish design. 

Its advanced features and affordable price point make it a strong contender in the non-Tesla electric car market. I would have put something other than the ID.3 on the list, but it did crop up several times in a few Reddit threads.

Alternatives to Model Y

1. Volkswagen ID.4

The VW ID.4 is one of the top contenders for the best non-Tesla electric car in the market. Its sleek design and impressive range offer a compelling choice for eco-conscious drivers.

The ID4 boasts advanced features and cutting-edge technology, providing a seamless driving experience (and perhaps looks that make it stand out!).

2. Audi Q4 e-tron

The Audi Q4 is another strong competitor in the electric vehicle segment. Known for its luxurious appeal and exceptional performance, the Q4 combines style, power, and sustainability. 

With its spacious interior and advanced safety features, the Q4 offers a comfortable and secure ride for both city and long highway drives. Plus, you get to enjoy actual ultrasonic parking sensors rather than Tesla Vision (which uses only cameras and has gained a bad reputation due to a worse overall experience).

3. Hyundai IONIQ 5

The Hyundai IONIQ 5 is a game-changer in the world of electric cars. With its futuristic and progressive design, the IONIQ 5 stands out. It offers an impressive driving range and innovative features, making it a worthy alternative to the Tesla Model Y.

4. Kia EV6

The Kia EV6 is a stylish electric powerhouse that deserves a spot on any electric car enthusiast's list. With its sleek exterior and spacious interior, the EV6 combines elegance and practicality. It offers impressive acceleration, range, and advanced safety and technology features. The EV6's striking looks and excellent performance make it a viable alternative to the Tesla Model Y.

Alternatives to Model X

While the Tesla Model X may be a popular choice for those seeking an electric SUV, other alternatives are worth considering. Let's take a look at two of the top contenders in this segment:

1. Volkswagen ID. Buzz

The Volkswagen ID. Buzz is an exciting electric vehicle that offers a unique blend of retro design and modern technology. Its spacious interior and impressive range make it an ideal choice for those who value style and practicality. 

The ID Buzz also boasts advanced safety features and a proper 7-seater van experience which many Reddit users love. 

2. Mercedes EQS SUV

The Mercedes EQS SUV combines luxury and sustainability in one stunning package. With its sleek design, comfortable interior, and cutting-edge features, the EQS SUV captures the attention of those looking for a high-end electric vehicle. 

When comparing these alternatives to the Tesla Model X, it's important to consider factors such as charging infrastructure, price, performance, safety features, and brand reputation. By doing so, you can make an informed decision and select the best non-Tesla electric car that suits your needs and preferences.

Alternatives to Model S

1. Audi e-tron GT

The Audi e-tron GT is a top contender for those seeking a non-Tesla electric car with impressive features. With its sleek and sporty design, the e-tron GT appeals to drivers who crave style, ride comfort and performance.

2. Porsche Taycan

If you're searching for a high-performance electric car that rivals the Tesla Model S, look no further than the Porsche Taycan. Designed with precision and engineering excellence, the Taycan offers a thrilling driving experience coupled with the elegance and prestige associated with the Porsche brand.

3. Mercedes EQS

Merging innovation and elegance, the Mercedes EQS is a non-Tesla electric car catering to drivers prioritising a luxurious and technologically advanced driving experience. The EQS exemplifies Mercedes' commitment to sustainable mobility with its striking design and cutting-edge features.

What are the trade-offs when choosing a non-tesla car?

While there are many great alternatives to Tesla electric cars, it's important to consider the trade-offs you may encounter when choosing a non-Tesla EV. Below are some significant factors to keep in mind:

  • Limited access to Supercharger network: One of the major advantages of owning a Tesla is the extensive Supercharger network, which allows for quick and convenient charging. However, non-Tesla electric cars lack full access to this network (some are open), meaning you may need to rely on slower charging options or find alternative charging stations.
  • Less refined infotainment system: Tesla has set the bar high when it comes to their intuitive and feature-rich infotainment systems. Some non-Tesla electric cars may not offer the same level of refinement, which could affect your overall driving experience.
  • Less efficient cars: Tesla is known for their impressive range and efficiency. While non-Tesla electric cars have made significant strides, they may not match the efficiency of Tesla's vehicles, potentially leading to shorter driving distances between charges.
  • Much less of a "fun" factor: Tesla cars have become synonymous with exhilarating acceleration and a thrilling driving experience. While non-Tesla electric cars can still be enjoyable to drive, they may not provide the same level of excitement and "fun" factor as their Tesla counterparts.

Ultimately, the best non-Tesla electric car for you will depend on your budget, desired performance, safety requirements, and the level of comfort you seek in your vehicle. 

Browse the latest EVs here and see if a monthly car subscription is a good option. 

Get £50 credit when you switch to Octopus Energy!
Click here and switch today!
This is a referral link, we get a commission at no cost to you.

Browse all cars available on subscription

There are hundreds of cars available via UK subscription companies.

Article sources
Our writers are required to use primary sources of information to support their content. These include research from authoritative brands, government data sets, first-hand experience where relevant and advice from industry experts.

We also reference useful information from other reputable websites where appropriate and data is fact-checked. See our editorial guidelines.
Privacy policy & advertising disclosure